Sierra wants public hearing on plant
Published on -6/23/2009, 12:05 PM
Printer-friendly version
E-Mail This Story
By MIKE CORN
The Kansas Sierra Club, joined by the environmental legal group EarthJustice, has asked for a public hearing in Sunflower Electric's proposed construction of an 895 megawatt coal-fired power plant near Holcomb.
The letter making the request was delivered Monday to the Kansas Department of Health and Environment.
KDHE spokeswoman Maggie Thompson said the agency is reviewing the letter -- a five-page document that outlines some elements in a settlement agreement between Sunflower and Gov. Mark Parkinson just days after he took office.
"In short, Sunflower must submit a new permit application with analyses of the facility it now actually proposes to construct... ." the letter states.
KDHE on Friday received a revised permit application from Sunflower for the 895-megawatt unit that was agreed upon by Sunflower and Parkinson.
Previously, Sunflower had proposed the construction of two 700-megawatt units at Holcomb. That request, however, was rejected by KDHE Secretary Rod Bremby, a decision that had been supported by then-Gov. Kathleen Sebelius and Parkinson when he was lieutenant governor.
In a surprise move to most observers, Parkinson made overtures for a compromise almost immediately after being sworn in as governor. Less than a week later, the agreement was announced.
In the letter, Sierra and EarthJustice are requesting the public get the chance to comment on the power plant prior to a permit being issued.
"Building a massive, new polluting coal facility will have serious long-term consequences for Kansas, and the public's voice should be heard on such an important matter," said Stephanie Cole, spokeswoman for Sierra.
The agreement, she said, was between the "governor and Sunflower and there wasn't any input from the public."
Both Parkinson and Sunflower put the public input issue squarely in KDHE's lap.
"The governor agrees that public input is an important part of the permitting process," Parkinson's spokeswoman said in an e-mail, "and he trusts that KDHE will allow for public input when it is appropriate."
"The decision regarding additional public hearings will, of course, be made by KDHE," Sunflower spokeswoman Cindy Hertel said in a statement via e-mail this morning. "As we have done in the past, we will meet all of KDHE's requests and regulations."
"We haven't heard whether that will come to pass," she said by telephone. "It's up to them."
Exactly what the process will be for the permitting of a new power plant is uncertain, Thompson said.
"I don't have an idea of a timeline," she said.
An electronic copy of the application from Sunflower was submitted to KDHE on Friday, with Sierra's request Monday.
Sunflower's request, contained in a 17-page document, for the most part, updates its previous permit request with changes noted.
A cover letter reports the compromise represents a 36-percent reduction in emissions across the board.
In its letter, EarthJustice points to the settlement agreement and an energy bill approved by the Kansas Legislature as both suggesting that a permit will be all but automatically issued.
"Additionally, the settlement agreement purports to provide that Sunflower need not comply with the hazardous air pollutant major source requirements of the Clean Air Act," the letter states. "The legality of these directives aside, and without waiving any right or claim against them, federal and state law both mandate that the public receive notice and an opportunity to comment ... We ask you to ensure that this public process occurs fully and fairly."
In addition to the public hearing process, Sierra said it also reserves the right to request a full evidentiary hearing.
While the letter was signed by two EarthJustice attorneys representing Sierra Club, Cole declined to say if legal action might follow if the public hearing request is denied.
"No options are off the table," she said. "This is something we feel is a significant threat to public health."
I now know why the movie producers of National Lampoon Vacation movies picked a baboon named Eddie from Coolidge, Kansas(not far from Holcomb) to represent backward thinking. Obviously the coal companies also recognized this.
(Posted by: Cares about kids!)
Sierra & Earth Justice: 6/25/2009
Hey cares about kids....okay, how about we just ship coal to Mexico and let them build much much dirtier plants and then buy electricity from them....wake up people. These are the same people that promote electric cars, but how do you charge them with no power plants. Wind energy helps, but you need a base line energy source. Wake up America!!!!
(Posted by: wants a future for your kids)
: 6/24/2009
If Seirra had it's way we would all be living in caves while surviving on cockroaches, but of course that other radical, anti-human organization, PETA, would frown upon that.
(Posted by: Jed)
sitting in the dark: 6/23/2009
I hope all you people who oppose this new power plant don't mind sitting in the dark and roasting in the heat, because that is what will happen if we don't build more power plants now. There is also another benefit...jobs and a lot of money put back into the Kansas economy...I think we need this now and in the future...get your heads out of the trees you are hugging and embrace the future progress of our state, we need more power now.
(Posted by: Cares about progress)
Power: 6/23/2009
So how do you propose powering your computer so you can read the news? Current trends with all the electronic gadgets everyone wants puts us at a decline in available power.
(Posted by: )
Sierra & Earth Justice: 6/23/2009
Thank goodness for these two organizations. I hope they suceed in blocking the building of the coal plant.
(Posted by: Cares about kids!)
COMMENT ON THIS STORY
All comments are subject to approval before being posted. Please keep comments constructive and relevant. Opinions certainly can be expressed, but comments that are rude, abusive, slanderous, threatening, sexually oriented, contain profanity or are vulgar will not be tolerated. Comments will not be edited. Any comment that violates the above-listed rules will be deleted.







